– Don Simon
| 2025 – Jeff Benditt |
| 2024 – Norm Dethloff |
| 2023 – Jeff Benditt |
| 2022 – Steve Czapla |
| 2021 – Bill Griffiths |
| 2020 – COVID-19 |
| 2019 – Mike Louella |
| 2018 – Pete McCorry |
| 2017 – Steve Newman |
| 2016 – Jerry Boland |
| 2015 – Scott Boland |
| 2014 – Bill Griffiths |
| 2013 – Adam Beal |
| 2012 – Bill Nigh |
| 2011 – Terry McLaughlin |
| 2010 – Ted Sideras |
| 2009 – Mike Louella |
| 2008 – Scott Simon |
| 2007 – Henry Opacki |
| 2006 – Scott Pitel |
| 2005 – Don Simon |
| 2004 – Gary Frazee |
| 2003 – Brian McMahon |
| 2002 – Don Simon |
| 2001 – Jay Jannis |
| 2000 – Jay Jannis |
| 1999 – Jay Jannis |
| 1998 – Bob Glasson |
| 1997 – Tom Freemer |
| 1996 – Clyde Furness |
| 1995 – Don Simon |
| 1994 – John Kaleda |
| 1993 – Tom Freemer |
| 1992 – B. Soprano |
| 1991 – J. Hemple |
| 1990 – Bill Cook |
| 1989 – Bob Glasson |
| 1988 – Don Kaleda |
| 1987 – H. Bickel |
| 1986 – Jack Leo |
FIVE POINTS GOLF CLUB 